Substrates, Ferts, Lighting and Co2

Discussion in 'Planted Tanks' started by Sean J, Jul 11, 2011.

  1. Sean J

    Sean J

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2009
    Messages:
    3,835
    Likes Received:
    36
    Location:
    Randburg JHB
    So, getting things going from the other thread, we all now know that in order to have healthy planted tanks we need the Following:

    Substrates: Stuff Like JBL, ADA, Controsoil, Flourite, etc...

    In my experience, inert substrates like Pool Filter Sand don't work as well as nutrient rich substrates. Unfortunately, being South Africa, we don't get much of the quality substrates that are available overseas. So we have to make do with a few alternatives, like using PFP and chemicult as a planting medium. While this does work, you don't see as good a growth pattern as with nutritious substrates like ADA or Controsoil. Also, it's messy when one wants to rescape the tank. Other than that, pool filter sand is white, and not as attractive as a darker substrate. Flourite is good, but it's the only substrate that we really have available in this country. It's very high in iron, but not much else, that would be very beneficial to the plants. It would be a great planting medium for Swords and Crypts, but additional root supplementation would be required as these plants are heavy root feeders.

    Ferts: Like Seachem Flourish, Tropica Plant Nutrition, Kent Ferts, Brightwells Ferts, EI, etc...

    There are a bunch of products locally available to do the job. I know the best plant growers are using EI and Micros to get the best out of their systems. But there are other alternatives in the bottled form. Prof Dirk also makes his own range of Ferts. The ferts are used up by the plants while they convert Co2 to O2. This is a vital step in the chain of providing your plants with a stable supply to make sure that no deficiencies in the plant occur.

    Lighting: T5, Metal Halide, PL, etc...

    Lighting is the growth determinator of plants. More lighting, means quicker growth, increased uptake of ferts and increased uptake of Co2. The more lighting you have above your tank, the more you will have to dose, and the more Co2 you will have to inject. Lighting systems vary. For shallow tanks, T8 tubes, or even Compact Fluorescent energy savers will do the job. For tanks that are roughly 45-50cm tall, T5's will get better depth penetration. And for taller tanks, Metal Halides will make sure you get light penetration all the way to the bottom of the tank.

    Co2: The building blocks of planted tanks.

    In my opinion, the single most important thing for a planted tank, is Co2 injection. Whether it be from a compressed canister, or from a DIY unit, Co2 injection is the life blood of the planted aquarium. Co2 regulates the rate of Photosynthesis that the plant will undertake. Obviously Lighting will also play a major role in this process, but if there is no Co2, there will be no photosynthesis. The more stable the supply of Co2, the better, that is why I would always recommend the use of a solenoid regulator on a pressurized bottle. Fire extinguishers do the job just fine, and they are easy to come by. Builders warehouse stocks them.

    So, this is just a dummies guide, written by a dummy, but I am sure that it will be of use to everyone here who wants to start a great looking planted tank. Who knows, maybe next year there will be loads more entries into the international aquascaping contests...

    Anyone else who wants to give their input, is more than welcome: @wearsbunnyslippers @Rudi @Algae Wizard @Zoom @Laure
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 2, 2016
  2. Guest




  3. Zoom

    Zoom Retired Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 13, 2009
    Messages:
    8,469
    Likes Received:
    119
    Location:
    Jhb- Fourways
    @slagter, I feel honored that you feel you would want to put my name next to those guys... I by no means qualify myself as an "aquascaper"... but just a copier of what these guys are doing in their tanks. I had a recent chat with Laure and one thing I think we can all agree on... no 2 tanks are the same, and no 2 solutions will work with the same results! There are just too many varying differentials within the tanks, and I think what we need to aim for is finding what works for each individual.

    This comes down to personal testing... with the 3 elements of light, fertz and CO2, you need to tweek the set up to meet your personal requirements.

    We also need to bare in mind that time constraints and budget should actually also be considered within those elements. Let's face it, if you have not got the time to be dosing your tank every day, checking your CO2 set up regularily, and keeping up with the required maintenance, then don't waste your time with it. Let's be honest here... nothing beats the look of an absolutely stunning planted tank, BUT don't forget the hours and hours of research and work that went into that. If you just don't have the time.... then don't be intimidated with a low tech set up. You can create some of the most stunning scapes with easy growing plants, low light, and minimal fertilizing.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 2, 2016
  4. wearsbunnyslippers

    wearsbunnyslippers aquascaper

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2009
    Messages:
    235
    Likes Received:
    128
    Location:
    Cape Town
    wow dood, that's a lot of topics to cover in one post...

    firstly you started with substrates so i will.

    if plants have roots they want to feed from them. anything that a plant manufactures is expensive in terms of building blocks for the plant, so if they do not need them, they will stop making them, kill them off or cannibalize them. so again, if a plant has roots, it wants to use them. aquatic plants can and do foliar feed, meaning they take in nutrients from their leaves. but why put all your eggs in one basket and only use substrate ( root ) feeding or only use column ( foliar ) dosing. if you want to grow decent healthy plants you will need an enriched substrate. please don't post stories about how you have grown massive swords etc. in plain pool filter sand.. from the moment you added fish and fish food to your tank, it stopped being plain pool filter sand and started enriching itself. this is nowhere near nutritious enough and if you absolutely have to post about how big your swords got in plain gravel, please also post about how big their root systems were... now i am not saying you cant use plain pool filter sand, but everything will take longer and you will not be able to grow some plants. to speed things up you can add some peat, not pfp but regular peat ( you can also use brown coal or leonardite if you have available ). just a sprinkling on the glass will do. this has the benefit of being already almost done with the decomposition stage and will acidify your substrate slightly with the release of humic, fulvic and tannic acids. this will kick start your bacteria colony as well as providing a perfect environment for nutrients like iron to be bioavailable. that's another thing, just coz its there doesn't make it available to plants, that's like saying lets add some charcoal because plants need carbon. you can also add some macro nutrients at this stage, some calcium, magnesium and potassium and then cap this off with plain old gravel or pool filter sand. if this sounds like a mission just for you substrate then stop reading and forget about planted tanks... now instead of going through all this hassle you can buy planted substrates as mentioned by slagter. some of these are complete substrates meaning the don't need to be capped and others need to be capped. the ones that need to be capped are usually a mix of the ingredients i have already listed. the ones that don't need to be capped usually contain clay as well and are fired to stop them breaking down too quickly.

    ferts come in two major groupings, macro's and micro's or trace elements. macro's are anything that a plant uses a lot of, these are nitrogen ( N ) phosphorous ( P ) and potassium ( K ). micro's are anything that the plant requires in trace amounts like iron ( Fe ), copper ( Cu ), manganese ( Mn ), zinc ( Zn ), boron ( B ), molybdenum ( Mo ) and magnesium ( Mg ) mostly. these are all combined in organic processes into the building block of the plant itself and in the chemical reactions used to make food etc. in a regular low light community tank with some anubias and java fern there should be enough nutrients from fish and food waste for plants to grow. most fish food contains ash as a filler which is high in phosphates and most organic waste will break down and release nitrogen. with regular feeding and water changes the trace elements will also be provided. a planted tank is underwater gardening, every gardener understands the need to provide fertilizers for their gardens to grow and flourish and the same goes for planted tanks. for healthy plants you will need to add some sort of fertilizer. the easiest way of doing this is with a water soluble aquatic plant fertilizer but there are cheaper alternatives that give you more control. foliar feeding which is adding ferts to your water column also known as column dosing improves the plants ability to take up nutrients through its roots and root feeding improves the plants foliar feeding capabilities, so instead of relying on just one technique, why not use both and get the best of both worlds, as well as healthier plants and a more stable system.

    light is the accelerator pedal in your planted tank. in a low light tank you can have greener, healthier, lusher plants by adding co2 and ferts, but you will not speed up their growth and you will not be able to grow plants that require a higher light threshold by doing this.

    co2 + h2o + light = o2 + carbohydrates

    increasing co2 does not increase the light uptake, all this does is free up the plant from needing to make expensive co2 capturing structures and allows it to focus on making more chlorophyll. the same goes for adding ferts. this is why adding co2 and ferts to a low light tank makes the plants look fuller and healthier, because they are. they are devoting more of their energy to growing more leaves and being more green to capture more light. too little light stimulates the production of gibberellins which increase internode length, this is why plants that grow in the shade tend to be leggy. if you increase your light and not add ferts or co2, the plants are basically scavenging for building blocks and having to make lots of expensive co2 capturing structures and rubisco which deplete the plants resources. some nutrients in plants are transportable, potassium especially, so plants can move them around where required, and often the best place to find these elements are in the plants own leaves. that is why you can immediately spot a potassium deficiency as pinholes in older leaves as the plants have removed it to use in the newer leaves.
     
    Sean J likes this.
  5. OP
    Sean J

    Sean J

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2009
    Messages:
    3,835
    Likes Received:
    36
    Location:
    Randburg JHB
    Awesome Post Raymond!

    I was well aware that I was, very basically, covering a whole bunch of things in one post. I was hoping to just touch on a few things regarding planted tanks, and the basic needs of a planted tank. Your post has explained, in a lot more detail, what I was trying to do. I appreciate it.

    I have been looking into the idea that temperature also plays a significant role in the growth of plants recently. It would seem that at higher temps, the plants seem to grow marginally faster than they would at lower temps. Have you ever had any experience with this Raymond? I remember my old 800mm tall tank. I had 4 pretty big Discus in there so the temp was always around 29 degrees, and my plants went absolutely ballistic in that tank. So maybe there is some truth in the theory? Although, the hotter the water, the less Oxygen, and more Co2 would be present? Perhaps this explains it?

    Thanks again for explaining, and a great post.
     
    boebie likes this.
  6. Zoom

    Zoom Retired Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 13, 2009
    Messages:
    8,469
    Likes Received:
    119
    Location:
    Jhb- Fourways
    @slagter. Would this only be specific to plants that can handle the higher temps?
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 2, 2016
  7. wearsbunnyslippers

    wearsbunnyslippers aquascaper

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2009
    Messages:
    235
    Likes Received:
    128
    Location:
    Cape Town
    i was maintaining my tank at 30 degrees while i had discus, and my plants also grew like crazy. i didnt really notice a significant difference dropping to 28 and now 25, my plants still grow like crazy... a few hours after lights on my tank is bubbling like a champagne glass, so i don't think they could grow any quicker...
     
  8. OP
    Sean J

    Sean J

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2009
    Messages:
    3,835
    Likes Received:
    36
    Location:
    Randburg JHB
    Most plant tropical species will handle the higher temps, except for Aquatic Moss species.

    True, I guess when you don't limit anything for the plants, then growth will be steady. Perhaps the temp will play a role when something like Light is limited? Maybe it's like fish, the hotter the water, the quicker they metabolize?
     
  9. wearsbunnyslippers

    wearsbunnyslippers aquascaper

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2009
    Messages:
    235
    Likes Received:
    128
    Location:
    Cape Town
    as slagter said, mosses don;t like warm temps 25 or below is best...
     

Recent Posts

Loading...
Similar Threads - Substrates Ferts Lighting Forum Date
Comparing substrates - please help with a protocol ... Anything DIY related Dec 29, 2012
Changing substrates General Discussions Jul 13, 2012
Zooms Article 4- Fertilizers, Substrates and CO2 Articles Oct 20, 2011
Alternative,nutritious substrates. Planted Tanks Aug 11, 2011
Planting Substrates Planted Tanks Sep 3, 2010
My Planted 3ft tank with CO2 and substrates Planted Tanks Oct 6, 2009
Aquaforest firtalizer as well as ferts with shrimp Advanced Topics Jan 19, 2021

Share This Page