On Thursday night i got home and noticed something unusual in the darkness if my tank. I turned on the light and found half my fish dead and the rest in distress. I looked at my control unit and saw my pH was 5.5 when it was 7.0 that morning when i left for work. i immediately started flushing the water, the air pump was already on, there were other actions i took and i know some people will jump up and down about but i did save all my smaller fish that werent already dead. Although i havent tested my CO2 bottle the only thing i can think of is it ran low and the solenoid valve couldnt control the flow and it dumped into the aquarium. The death toll that afternoon was 8 ottos, 2 rummy nose, 2 leopard corrys, my last cardinal, CAE and host heart breaking 4 of my 5 discus. The fourth was dead by the morning. The female that pulled through was from my breading pair i had posted about awhile ago. She is however now very shy and i dont know how she will take to being alone for the next few months as i want to now take the opportunity to redo the scaping. Pic 1 was my breeding male, i loved his fins, no idea where the strip comes from. Pic 3 what i fished out that night. Pic 4 something i saw was a white string coming from the gill flap of the one discus, is this tape worm or worm of some kind or is it just slime? Pic 5 my female spent around 12 hours laying on her side and now swimming ok but needs some TLC. I have had so many experiences with these guys, really miss watching them.
Oster (medium) it didnt pop or anything like that from high pressure. i still need to get the time to remove the solenoid from the tank and manually open the bottle to see if any gas comes out. I got a feeling this happened sometime in the afternoon. If i had not worked late i might have been home to see it and save all my fish. The discus were around 10cm. i got them last year May for my birthday by my wife.
That is a sad day.....I had a similar experience with CO2. I lost Kutubu rainbows, 2 dwarf rainbows, 1 threadfin, 2 Gertrudae and 2 julii cories One of the worst days I've ever had From hobby to addiction
Sorry for your loss Ally. Is the solenoid not controlling the flow when the cylinder gets low a common problem with CO2 systems?
Eish, that's bad, my commiserations. I have started running CO2 on my tank now, and your experience makes me think I should really keep a close eye on things, before I put any expensive fish in there. At the moment I have four Apistos and a few corys in the tank, so not quite as expensive as discus. But still, would not like to lose any fish if I can help it. Good luck with the recovery op.
I'm so sorry for you losses. Those were stunning discus you had there. I read somewhere about this thing called EOTD which is End Of Tank Dump. It's something to do when there's less co2 in the cylinder and the pressure in your co2 cylinder is lower than the pressure in your tank which results it in dumping all the remainder of the co2 in your tank. This freaks me out and im so hesitant to connect my co2 to my tank. Sorry again for your loss bud. Wish you all the luck on the new setup and fish
That sucks, I had this happen to me a couple of years ago and lost 6 Denison barbs. Agree with kovi, end of tank dump when pressure drops below the normal operating (filled) pressure and the regulator allows the balance of the CO2 gas to flow into your tank, I think there are regulators that avoid this, but can't tell you which they are
Hi Waterboy, ya that is what i am assuming, i know it happens on paintball bottles too. ive been so busy with repairing our house and working late that i havent had the time to do an RCA on the CO2 system. Just doing water changes in case of a ammonia spike as i cant find the bodies of 6 ottos. Thanks everyone for the well wishes. I been using CO2 for almost 2 years, this was the end of my second refill and just lost track of how long it had been running, i dont thing the gauges are that accurate on the unit, no name units. ive got a 9kg bottle and not sure if that would mean a bigger dump compared to a smaller bottle. Im in 2 minds to go minimal plant and more log discus tank with sump or marine. My high tech planted tank went through many changes and have tried a couple adjustments. I think a more low tech discus setup will give me more time looking after the fish and not the scaping. but this will only happen in January. Again thanks for all the wishes
As a recent convertee to CO2 this is rather scary! I assume that the solenoid was controlling pH via the CO2 flow. My little tank with its handful of cheap fish is doing really well (thank goodness) but I only have a baby disposable CO2 tank controlled by a needle valve / regulator which I have set manually. Do these valves also potentially suffer from low CO2 pressure issues and sparge the tank at the end? The solenoid I have is only used an on/off for when the lights are on or off. Regards Barry
@Ally, from what I have read, having a high tech planted Discus tank is almost impossible. Have a look in the Discus section, going back some time, and you will see some discussion on this.