CO2 & Plecos?

Discussion in 'General Discussions' started by Skye01, Feb 15, 2012.

  1. Dirk

    Dirk Dwarf Catfish

    Joined:
    Feb 10, 2009
    Messages:
    2,514
    Likes Received:
    81
    Location:
    Somerset West
    Hi Reedfish,

    If you say that you would be "poisoning" your fishes with CO2 this is almost a double statement in that on the one hand, if you would administer too much CO2 you would cause the pH to go down drastically, and this could theoretically kill your fishes because of a pH crash, but on the other hand we associate CO2 with suffocation and think that this could cause fishes to die. Normally what happens in a planted tank is that you regulate the CO2 in any case not to cause the pH to crash (or that is how you are supposed to do it!) and then the amount of free CO2 is not too high. You must also remember that CO2 fertilization causes plants to produce oxygen, O2, and this is what the fishes need to survive, so this is good.

    However, plecs do not have a lower threshold or tolerance for CO2 and would actually handle a pH crash better because they can handle lower pH, so I can still state that this business of plecs being more sensitive to CO2 is not correct, we do not need to speculate about it.

    Kind regards,

    Dirk
     
  2. Guest




  3. Reedfish

    Reedfish Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2011
    Messages:
    13,311
    Likes Received:
    3,714
    Location:
    UK
    Dirk,

    Yes, too much CO2 would poison fish from 2 angles.

    Firstly, the amount of CO2 dissolved in the water would be more than the fish can handle.
    And secondly as you have pointed out, too much CO2 would cause a ph crash.

    I have read recently on a specialist Plec Forum that someone killed their breeding colony of Queen Arabesques.
    In their ignorance they used pure RO without some sort of remineralistion. The Ph crashed and all the fish died.
    As far as I am aware, CO2 was not used in this case. But it just shows how unstable pure RO water is.
     
  4. Dirk

    Dirk Dwarf Catfish

    Joined:
    Feb 10, 2009
    Messages:
    2,514
    Likes Received:
    81
    Location:
    Somerset West
    Hi Reedfish,

    Thanks for your reply and indicating that this story comes from this plec forum. It just goes to show exactly what I stated earlier in the thread. Someone uses RO water and CO2 fertilization. This means he does not understand the first thing about CO2 fertilization because if you want to use you MUST ALWAYS have carbonate hardness in the water. So this is as far as I am concerned completely ridiculous and that person was being plain stupid to have done this and then murdered all his Arabesques.

    But what I think I am now detecting is that this story has now gone further, and some other idiot has made the interpretation that plecos are sensitive to CO2, which is nothing else than the biggest lot of rubbish because someone stupid has now made the next incorrect deduction.

    In my opinion, this illustrates the dangers of the internet, there is no checking of the correctness of statements that people make and then we have one stupid misunderstanding after the next.

    All that this does is that it means someone (like me) needs to do a whole lot of corrective explanation to get the matter straightened out.

    I hope that you can understand my frustration with this sort of thing.

    Kind regards,

    Dirk
     
  5. Algae Wizard

    Algae Wizard

    Joined:
    Mar 12, 2009
    Messages:
    168
    Likes Received:
    1
    Location:
    JHB
    Hi Prof Dirk Long time no speak

    I have kept all kinds of catfish in CO2 injected planted tanks for many years.
    I have 2 15 year old talking cats who have been in Co2 planted tanks since day 1
    The main thing is to keep your KH at minimum of 4 so that you don't have a PH crash by adding CO2
    also a good rule of thumb is 1 bubble CO2 per 10L of water in your tank per minute.

    I agree with Prof Dirk about RO
    All I do now is filter my WC water through 2 carbon cannisters as I do not trust Jozi water anymore.
     
  6. Dirk

    Dirk Dwarf Catfish

    Joined:
    Feb 10, 2009
    Messages:
    2,514
    Likes Received:
    81
    Location:
    Somerset West
    Hi Angus,

    Yes, long time no speak, it is about high time we had a private natter again.

    I am very glad that you have related your experiences here, this just goes to show that this is a woefully incorrect rumour and that loricariad cats are pretty tough and definitely tolerate CO2 very well.

    Also, that one needs to keep your KH to 4 if you want to use CO2 fertilization is critically important.

    RO water and CO2 fertilization is a disaster. If you just let RO water stand in an open bucket the pH will drop to 4 once the CO2 from the atmosphere dissolves in it, you do not even need to inject any CO2 into it. If you inject CO2, well then you are headed for pH below 4.......... and then DISASTER!

    So this should actually be a warning about RO water as well, it is nice and soft, but it is difficult to keep water conditions (pH) constant under these conditions.

    Kind regards,

    Dirk
     
  7. Double-D

    Double-D David

    Joined:
    Aug 15, 2011
    Messages:
    452
    Likes Received:
    9
    Location:
    Secunda, Mpumalanga
    @Dirk Bellstedt I have also stated that they are quite resiliant towards CO2 as I keep 2 ancistrus in a 110L planted tank running 2bps which is exponentialy higher than the 11bpm rule of thumb. I do however have secondary airation but only for the purpose of surface agitation. Which means that the water collumn doesn't saturate. Our water has good parameters of 6-8Kh and 7.2pH matured of course. My tank pH is a healthy 6.8 and just before maitenance 6.6 which calculates to a 0.2pH drop over a 2 week period. I would say Kh is the critical factor but also saturation is just as important. Your thoughts on this?

    Sent from my BlackBerry 9530 using Tapatalk
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 2, 2016
  8. Dirk

    Dirk Dwarf Catfish

    Joined:
    Feb 10, 2009
    Messages:
    2,514
    Likes Received:
    81
    Location:
    Somerset West
    Double-D,

    The proof of the pudding would lie in the accurate measurement of pH if you are using this procedure. As you say, if you aerate you are removing CO2, but you are also adding too much CO2 so we just simply would not know how much CO2 your water contains and what the pH is as a result. This actually sounds contradictory, you are adding CO2 and you are blowing it off as soon as you add it. I would rather suggest that you use a powerhead for your surface agitation and then that you add less CO2, this is more logical to me.

    Kind regards,

    Dirk
     
  9. Double-D

    Double-D David

    Joined:
    Aug 15, 2011
    Messages:
    452
    Likes Received:
    9
    Location:
    Secunda, Mpumalanga
    Prof I use a submerged filter with an air induction pipe so the airation is very little in fact if compared to an air pump. Is there a way to test the CO2 saturation in the water collumn? @Dirk Bellstedt

    Sent from my BlackBerry 9530 using Tapatalk
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 2, 2016

Recent Posts

Loading...
Similar Threads - Plecos Forum Date
Freebie: Common plecos Wanted/Swop/Freebies Nov 2, 2024
Starlight plecos L183 General Discussions Sep 10, 2024
Starlight plecos Community Tanks Feb 27, 2024
Wanted: Plecos L144, L201,L333 Wanted/Swop/Freebies May 5, 2022
What plecos is this. ID Needed Dec 12, 2021
Wanted : Plecos Wanted/Swop/Freebies Jan 6, 2021
Swop: 2 x Common Plecos to swop Wanted/Swop/Freebies Dec 29, 2020

Share This Page